Compare Vinal Siding To James Hardiplank

In a remodeling contractor survey done by hanley wood the mid range vinyl siding cost for a typical home 1 250 sq.

Compare vinal siding to james hardiplank.

By contrast vinyl siding is far thinner. Vinyl siding on a cape cod style home installed by siding windows group. Vinyl is one of the most affordable forms of siding but james hardie is not far behind. There are many reasons to choose james hardie fiber cement siding over vinyl the first of which is appearance.

The survey also reports an average cost to value return average percentage of cost. Just like real wood lap siding hardieplank is thick. This means that vinyl siding is about 2 1 2 times thinner than hardieplank. Between 0 040 and 046 inches thick.

While james hardie lp smartside and insulated vinyl siding are similarly priced they do have some variation. Many people find that there is no reason to pay such a high premium for hardie plank if lp offers great curb appeal and quality at a fraction of the cost. James hardie siding is over five times thicker than vinyl allowing for deeper grooves and a more authentic wood grain effect. This variation will be explained in further detail below.

Both fiber cement and vinyl siding seek to mimic that look but james hardie siding achieves this far better than vinyl can. The thin plastic material of vinyl simply can t match this beauty. Additionally vinyl siding is predisposed to warping due to heat. Lp smart siding is a more upscale looking higher quality product than vinyl which is the cheapest option.

It easily stands up to the elements resisting damage from wind rain freezing temperatures and hail and gives homes years of protection with low maintenance. This is because the material used for james hardie is heavier than vinyl so the installation will require specialized installation and more labor. While thicknesses do vary an average thickness of hardieplank is 5 16 inch or over 1 4 inch thick. Of siding installed in the us was about 14 300 according to the hanley wood remodeling costs report for 2020.

Both sidings are more affordable than most other materials. It does not burn melt or warp when exposed to heat though which is a significant advantage over vinyl siding. By contrast james hardie fiber cement siding is more durable and up to 5x thicker than vinyl siding. Where vinyl pulls ahead in cost is the installation.

The density of hardie boards helps to garner deep grooves and grains that truly look like real wood. The result is more elegant than vinyl which is plastic particularly on a historic home. And both forms of siding are designed to last for years which means fewer replacements and more money saved. Lastly because hardie board holds up against heat and cold better than vinyl siding hardie board does not become brittle with age.

Expense although james hardie is a wonderful siding brand one of its drawbacks is the fact that it s more expensive than vinyl.